Comparing Two Stories Activity
This comparing two stories activity has students sort 16 detail cards from Stone Soup and Nail Soup. Built for 1st to 3rd grade, with a Venn sheet, practice page and answer key included.
$6.97
Want this one free?
Tell us where to send it and it’s yours — no card, no catch.
One free resource per teacher. We’ll also send free teaching ideas each week — unsubscribe anytime.
Free teacher account · no credit card
Membership
Get every game, song, & printable
- Every game, on any device
- 6,500+ resources
- Assign online with HFT Classroom
Then $39.97/year · cancel anytime · See plans
- Instant digital download
- Printable PDF + answer key
- Made by real teachers
Teacher / Family membership
Teaching is easier with every resource
One membership for your whole year: 6,500+ worksheets, games, songs and videos for Preschool–6th, for your classroom or homeschool.
- Unlimited printables & downloads
- Every game, on any device
- Assign online with HFT Classroom
- Cancel anytime
Teacher / Family membership · 3 days free
Yearly
Monthly would be $119.64 a year
$3.33/month
Billed $39.97 once a year
You save $79.67 every year
Start My 3 Free Days$0 today · cancel anytime
Monthly
$9.97/month
Flexible, month to month
Yearly is just $3.33/mo. Switch and save $79.67
Start My 3 Free Days$0 today · cancel anytime
About this resource
Description
Teach young readers to compare and contrast two versions of the same tale with this comparing two stories activity. Many folktales are told in more than one country, and each version changes a few details while keeping the heart of the story. When students line up two versions side by side, they learn to notice what stays the same, what changes, and why a story can feel new each time it is told.
Students read two classic soup folktales: Stone Soup, a folktale from France, and Nail Soup, a folktale from Sweden. Then they cut out 16 soup detail cards. Each card names one story detail, such as who brings carrots or what the traveler drops in the pot. In small groups, students read a card, look back at the stories, and place it on the Stone Soup, Both Stories, or Nail Soup row of the sort mat. They write each card number on a Venn recording sheet and add one way the stories are alike and one way they are different. A compare and contrast stories activity like this one works well in reading centers, guided reading groups, or as a whole-class lesson.
What’s Included
- Cover page and a How to Use page for the teacher
- Two illustrated story pages: Stone Soup and Nail Soup
- 16 Soup Detail Cards on two cut sheets
- Three-row Soup Sort Mat
- Venn recording sheet
- 2nd grade practice worksheet with two versions of The Little Red Hen, multiple choice and a short response
- Answer keys for the sort, the Venn sheet and the practice page
Why Kids Love It
- The soup stories are short, funny and easy to retell.
- Sorting cards on the mat makes comparing details hands-on and active.
- The Venn sheet turns the sort into a clear picture of what is alike and what is different.
Teaching Ideas
Before you begin, read one story aloud and ask students to predict what might change in a version from another country. After the comparing two stories activity, invite students to write their own soup story with a new object in the pot, then compare it with a partner’s version. You can also pair the sort with two versions of Cinderella or another fairy tale your class loves.
Related Resources
What teachers say
Reviews
Write a review, earn store credit
Get 25¢ in credit for every approved review of a resource you’ve downloaded, played or purchased — up to 15 a month. Credit applies automatically to your membership payments, so your reviews can help pay for your membership.
Honest reviews only — any star rating earns the same. Program rules
Log in to write a review and earn store credit.
Meet two friends, then check off what they share and what makes each one different. This compare and contrast characters worksheet gives 1st graders a clear, no-prep sorting chart, with a complete answer key included.
This Big, Bigger, Biggest Worksheet gives first grade students fun practice comparing objects by size, labeling big, bigger, and biggest and circling the biggest and smallest. An answer key is included to make learning simple.
This same different picture worksheet asks 1st graders to circle the odd picture in four rows, then name one likeness and one difference, with an answer key included.
Using this Size Activity, students play Categories to practice identifying the sizes tall, short, big and small.
This comparing characters worksheet gives 1st graders a short story about two friends and a three-part chart for sorting what is alike and what is different. Answer key included, so checking takes seconds.
This same different objects worksheet asks 1st grade students to circle the object that changes color, size, or direction, then compare a crayon and a pencil. An answer key is included for quick checking.
A two-part Same Different Categories Worksheet where 1st graders circle the words that belong to a group, then find the one that does not. Answer key included for quick, no-prep sorting practice.
Using Characters, Settings, and Big Events Worksheet, students draw pictures and write a sentence for each to tell about the story elements in a book.
This compare two stories worksheet helps 1st grade readers compare Duck and Frog, two pond animals, with five bubble questions and an answer key, building strong compare and contrast skills.
This Comparing Seasons Venn Diagram Worksheet helps 1st graders sort six facts about summer and winter into a labeled Venn diagram. An answer key is included, making practice quick and easy to check.
Using this Green Eggs and Ham Worksheet, studentsread Green Eggs and Ham to compare and contrast the adventures the two characters have in the book.
Using Compare Contrast Book Covers Worksheet, students compare two books using information from the book cover to determine how they are alike and different.
Reviews
There are no reviews yet