Peanut Butter Brownies Reading Comprehension Worksheet

Reading with understanding means more than saying the words on the page, and this Peanut Butter Brownies reading comprehension worksheet gives second graders a warm, everyday story worth thinking about. Students read about a girl named Sophie who decides to bake peanut butter brownies for her family, measures and stirs every item into the bowl, waits while the pan cools, and finally shares the squares with the people she loves. Every question on the second page sends the reader back into the text for evidence, which is exactly the habit that comprehension assessments measure.

The sheet is built the way a busy classroom needs it. Page one holds the full story with a bright kitchen scene of Sophie and her brother Abel leaning over the frosted pan. Page two carries the name and date line, four multiple-choice questions with fill-in-the-bubble answers, and a written response that asks students to name how a character felt and to say how they know. Page three is the answer key. Print it as a whole-class reading lesson, use it in a small guided reading group, slide it into a literacy center, or send it home as review.

What’s Included

• A three-page printable PDF sized for standard letter paper
• An original 2nd grade story, written and measured on grade level
• A full-color illustration of the moment the brownies come out frosted
• Four multiple-choice questions with fill-in-the-bubble answer circles
• One short written response that asks for text evidence
• A complete answer key on the final page

Three things make this peanut butter brownies reading comprehension worksheet worth the printing. First, the story is short enough to finish in one sitting, so a second grader who is still building stamina reaches the questions with energy left to think. Second, every answer is recoverable from the text, so a student who is unsure has somewhere to go besides guessing, and a teacher can see at a glance whether a missed item was a reading problem or an attention problem. Third, the written response moves past recall into inference, asking the reader to decide how Abel felt and then to point at the sentence that proves it.

Teachers and parents can stretch this 2nd grade food worksheet well past a single lesson. Read the story aloud once, then have students reread it with a partner and underline the sentence that answers each question. Ask the class to retell the baking steps in order, which turns a comprehension sheet into a sequencing lesson. Let students write a short paragraph about a food they have helped to make at home, or draw the next scene in Sophie’s kitchen. For a small group, cover the answer choices and have students answer from memory first, then check themselves against the passage.

Related Resources

• Baseball Hat Reading Comprehension Worksheet
• Riding the Bus Reading Comprehension Worksheet
• So Sweaty Reading Comprehension Worksheet
• Story Elements Song