

Fantasy and Reality Reading Comprehension Worksheet
A Fantasy and Reality Reading Comprehension Worksheet where 2nd graders read a birthday story and sort what could really happen from what is make-believe. Answer key included, so genre practice takes no prep.
$6.97
Or free with a membership — get this and 10,000+ resources. See plans
Teaching is easier with a membership
Unlimited printables, games & videos for PreK–6th — for your classroom or homeschool. Cancel anytime.
Start your 3-day free trialNo commitment · Cancel anytime · Instant access to 10,000+ resources
About this resource
Description
Telling the difference between what could really happen and what is only imagined is one of the first genre skills a young reader builds, and this Fantasy and Reality Reading Comprehension Worksheet gives second graders a warm, funny story to practice it on. In “The Big Surprise!” a girl named Nevaeh plans a birthday party for her mom with help from Edward, the bear who lives next door, and a robin who ties ribbons with her beak. Everything about the baking, the frosting, and the hiding behind the couch could really happen — but talking animals could not. Sorting those two kinds of details apart is exactly what readers do when they identify a story as fantasy or as realistic fiction.
This 2nd grade fantasy and realism worksheet is built as a short reading-comprehension set. Students read the illustrated story on page one, then move to page two for three multiple-choice questions, a four-item Real or Make-Believe sort, and one written response that asks them to defend their thinking with a detail from the text. Use it as a whole-class mini-lesson, as independent morning work, in a small guided-reading group, or as a quick check before starting a longer genre unit. Everything is print-ready, so no preparation is needed beyond copying the pages.
What’s Included
- 1 print-ready PDF worksheet
- Answer key
- 1 original illustrated fantasy story, 3 multiple-choice questions, a 4-item real-or-make-believe sort, and 1 written response
There are three reasons this Fantasy and Reality Reading Comprehension Worksheet helps children learn the skill. First, both kinds of detail sit inside a single story, so students have to read closely instead of guessing from a cover or a title. Second, the multiple-choice questions and the sorting items ask the same thinking in two different formats, which builds flexibility before a test. Third, the final question requires text evidence, so children practice explaining how they know — the habit that carries this skill into every later reading standard.
Teachers and parents can stretch the lesson in simple ways. Read a favorite picture book aloud and pause to ask whether each event could really happen. Keep a two-column anchor chart on the wall and add examples all week. Have students rewrite one make-believe sentence from the story so that it becomes realistic, then compare versions with a partner. Older siblings can invent a fantasy sentence for a younger reader to catch. A quick sorting game with sentence strips also works well as a five-minute warm-up.
Related Resources
What teachers say
Reviews
You must be logged in to post a review.












Reviews
There are no reviews yet